CompareAn honest comparison

One platform, or separate LIMS, QMS, MES and ERP?

Many plants buy a LIMS, a QMS, an MES and an ERP as separate products — from several vendors, or as separate products from one vendor. Here is how that compares with one platform.

Side by side

Three ways to digitise the same plant.

Separate systems from several vendors, separate products from one vendor, and one platform compared
Separate systems, several vendors Separate products, one vendor One platform (Swat iQua Suite)
Databases & audit trails No: One per system Partly: Often one per product Yes: One database, one audit trail
Validation No: Each system, plus every interface Partly: Typically each product separately Yes: One validation effort; new modules inherit the controls
Users, roles & e-signatures No: Set up and maintained in each system Partly: May be shared, may not Yes: One set of users, roles and signatures
Linked records No: Through interfaces — or by hand Partly: Depends on how the products are integrated Yes: Deviation, CAPA, retest and release link automatically
Contracts & roadmaps No: Several Yes: One vendor Yes: One vendor, one roadmap
Rollout No: A project per system Partly: Often a project per product Yes: Module by module, typically 1–3 months to go live
Choice of each tool Yes: Best-of-breed in every area Partly: Limited to one vendor’s range Partly: One platform’s modules, plus API and imports for systems you keep

Keeping a system you are happy with? Swat iQua Suite connects to it through a versioned REST API and controlled imports.

See how it connects

When separate systems fit better

Best-of-breed has its place.

  • You already run a validated system that works well and covers a specialised need.
  • A group standard is set centrally and sites must use it.
  • You need deep functionality in one area that a broader platform does not cover.

In those cases, the questions to ask are about the joins: how records link across systems, how many audit trails an inspector will need, and who validates the interfaces.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Can’t find your answer? Talk to our team — we reply within one business day.

Is one platform a compromise in each area?

Not necessarily. Swat iQua Suite has 85+ modules across the lab, quality, manufacturing, materials and release. Judge each area you need in a demo against your own requirements.

Can we start with one area?

Yes. Licensing is modular: start with the area that hurts most and add the rest on the same records.

What about our ERP?

Many sites keep their finance ERP and run GMP processes in Swat iQua Suite, connected through the REST API or controlled imports.

About this comparison

Fair, general, and checked.

These comparisons describe general approaches in the market, not any specific vendor or product. Statements about Swat iQua Suite are our own; statements about other approaches describe what is typical and may not apply to every product.

Compare it on your own records.

Book a free, personalised demo and see Swat iQua Suite running your processes — then judge for yourself.

Download the brochure →